Unreal Tournament 2003 (Demo) review
Page 7 of 7
CONCLUSION AND OVERALL RATING:
The UT2003 demo was in interesting subject to review this extensively. With all of the pre-release hype about the game I (and many others) has many expectations as well as trepidations about this demo. Some of the previously shown stuff made it look like things were going in the EXACT direction many of us were hoping the game would go. Other things made it look as if some stuff was being taken either too far, or, in another direction than what players would expect. But, then again, this is the same sort of thing that happens with ANY follow-up/sequal type of game.
If I exclude everything I knew/know about UT and solely look at this demo as a product on to itself, I have to say the demo does a good job of showing me what the finished product will be like. Based upon that, I have to say that I am not sure I am going to purchase the full game (no that does NOT mean I am going to WAREZ it). So, why am I not sure about buying the game? Well, the demo was fun to play, but, it didn't give me that OMG this is the SH*T feeling.
Yes, the graphics are amazing. And yes, the amount of geometry in the levels is ENORMOUS. But, those aspects are all eye-candy. What counts is GAMEPLAY. Unfortunately, this is the one area where I felt the demo was the most lacking. I have reached a point where "strategic" gameplay has taken precidence over that of "scream and twitch". While the "scream and twitch" style of gameplay can give you 133t SKi11Z, it becomes repetitious over time. The person who can control item X or spot Y will usually win the game. There is not enough variety in that sort of gameplay to make it for me any more.
Bombing Run was created to try and add to both the variety and strategy of gameplay in UT2003. Unfortunately, the implimentation of that game type (as well as the map provided) did not particularly appeal to me. It came across a bit "too" linear with both teams just scrambling for the bomb. Strategy only comes into play when ppl play like a "team"...something that is sometimes hard to find on public online servers (mainly because everyone wants to be the quarterback and not the defensive lineman).
If I HAD to put an overall rating on the UT2003 demo it would be a VERY close line between Good and Average. The "look" of the game is better than average (my Good rating). But, the gameplay is essentially just a decent version of the "average" FPS. Gameplay wise, it doesn't really offer anything that makes it stand out above the pack.
And, unfortunately, item placement was used to define the gameplay flow rather than the environments. Because of this, the draw of a particular environment comes more from eye-candy than from the gameplay offered by the level design. As it is now, most of the environments are just "pretty" places to do battle for items. Since I place my rating focus on gameplay over eye-candy, I end up having to give UT2003 an overall rating of "Average".
Final Note: The one thing that kept creeping up in the back of my mind was the fact that the "goal" of the demo seemed to come across more like a "look what we can do" style of technology demo than the next "must have" FPS "game".
**************
COMPARISON CORNER:
This area is COMPLETELY separate from the review. In this section I am going to draw (some obvious) comparisons between aspect of UT2003 and other FPS games.
Shield Gun:
The piston animation looks a LOT like the Quantum Destabalizer weapon from SiN.
Bio Rifle:
With decrease in lifespan of bio-drops, this is an example of a weapon that has essentially become "less" powerful than the previous version. Why upgrade to a new "less" powerful version? Excluding that it's essentially the same as in UT.
Link Gun:
The alt-fire of the Link Gun is VERY simular to the alt-fire mode of a weapon in SiN. The lack of skill required to use the weapon helped it to become known as the "b*tch" gun. With it's long reach and ease of use does the Link Gun have a simular nickname in it's future?
Flak Cannon:
The decrease in spam has forced an increase in skill required to use the primary fire of this weapon which means it will proabaly see less use than the previous version from UT.
Lightning Gun:
Yet again, there would be "NO" reason to "upgrade" to a newer version of a weapon that is "less" useful than the previous one..."Video" flicker in a scope where the previous one had none, A trail leading back to my position where the original had none. There ARE other slug thrower weapons in UT2003. Therefore, a truely "updated" version of the original sniper rifle could have been created rather than a "new and improved" weapon that essentially does the same thing, just not as good.
Health (+5 Vial, +25 Cross, +100 Big Keg O' Health):
Unlike the UT health "boxes", these health items will not be as easily placed into a level in a "realistic" manner (as in on a shelf/table/etc.). Not a real biggie as ppl will model their own, however, it is just one thing for those that will not be able to model their own objects to consider.
Character Models:
The models in the demo look too much like the Quake 2 marine. The big heavy armored looks is okay, but it's been done before. It would have been nice to see something new in terms of style represented in the demo.
Gameplay Speed:
The speed of the gameplay IS faster than that of UT (but not as fast as Q3). Many ppl will not be happy with this as it was the slower pace of UT that allowed for more "strategy" within the gameplay.
Hardware Requirements:
About 12% of the gaming market is made up of ppl that are considered "hardcore" (as in upgrading their equipment for games and such). 65% of the market is made up of ppl that are NOT able/willing to upgrade for a single game. It's that 65% of the market that may not have the ability to play UT2003 in all it's graphical glory. A lot of these ppl have to reduce settings just to play UT at a decent (read: playable) framerate...what could they expect from UT2003?
Knowing the above, it's likely that there will be a great portion of the "potential customers" that will be unable, or unwilling, to buy UT2003 because of it's steap hardware requirements. One of which being the MINIMUM 3 Gig install. That may not sound like much to the "hardcore" (I have an 80+ Gig hard drive) crowd. But, the "majority" of ppl out there are still running much smaller hard drives than that. Time will tell what the future will hold for UT2003.
My prediciton for the sales of UT2003 is that they will be less than that of UT. One reason is because the advancements of gameplay found in the UT demo that lead to many word of mouth downloads, and eventual full version sales, are not present in the UT2003 demo. It comes across as more of the same in a prettier package.
Added:
Product reviewed: Unreal Tournament 2003 (Demo)
Reviewer: STATIC3D
Score: 7/10