Two months with Windows 8 review

Page 1 of 4

Microsoft logo
Microsoft's operating systems have come a long way since the 1990s. Before the introduction of Windows 95, many of the popularly used programs and games were DOS exclusive, but by the time that Windows 98 hit the scene the command-line-based DOS was pretty much a thing from the past. Windows 98 was succeeded by Windows Me, this operating system had a very short shelftime, it was notorious for its poor stability and many users complained it was a regression from Windows 98.

Then came Windows XP, this operating system was launched in October 2001 and although it was first met with harsh criticism, the operating system quickly gained a wide adoption. Windows Vista is widely regarded as one of Microsoft's biggest failures, at launch the operating system suffered from poor software compatibility and performance issues, and the operating system never managed to capture people's heart and mind. Windows 7 on the other hand was an instant success, even the beta version had a relatively huge install-base and many enthusiasts finally saw a reason to upgrade from Windows XP.

Windows 7 was basically an improved version of Windows Vista, it delivered a better performance as well as increased usability and functionality. Windows 7 resulted in many satisfied users and over time it managed to overtake Windows XP in terms of marketshare, but even today the over a decade-old Windows XP still stands surprisingly strong. According to a November 2012 marketshare report from Net Applications, Windows XP clings on to a marketshare of nearly 40 percent.

With Windows 8, Microsoft is steering its operating system into a radically different direction. In the last ten years we've seen a shift from desktop PCs to notebooks, and now some are prophesising the end of the PC era as smartphones and tablets are becoming increasingly commonplace. While Microsoft is the dominant player in the x86 operating system market, the software giant has had little success with smartphone and tablet products, these markets are largely dominated by Apple's iOS and Google's Android operating systems. With its back against the wall, Microsoft decided to make a major gamble by making massive changes to the user interface of Windows 8 to make it more usable on touch-based mobile devices.

The new user interface of Windows 8 was met with massive pre-launch criticism, enthusiasts complained about the new "Metro" user interface and the new app model, and several game developers proclaimed that Windows 8 would mean the end of PC gaming. Despite a big marketing campaign, Windows 8 seems to have failed to generate a big boost in PC demand and data from Net Applications shows the adoption rate of Windows 8 has now fallen behind Windows Vista's. But is Microsoft's new operating system really that bad? I've been using Windows 8 for close to two months now and in this desktop-oriented review I will explore whether the negative climate surrounding Windows 8 is justified.

Windows 8 logo




Low pricing
Initially, I didn't plan on updating to Windows 8 because the new "Metro' interface sounded like a really bad idea for anything non-touch - but the ultra-low upgrade pricing of Windows 8 changed my mind. In the past, upgrading to a newer version of Windows was relatively expensive, but the download-only launch upgrade offer to Windows 8 costs only 29.99EUR ($39.99), and even as little as 14.99EUR ($14.99) if you've bought a Windows 7 PC between June 2, 2012 and January 31, 2013. The low pricing is a welcome change from the expensive Windows upgrades from the past, but according to the rumor mill it fits in Microsoft's plan to switch to an annual release cycle for Windows. Future versions of Windows are expected to be relatively cheap as well, but will follow much quicker so Microsoft can adopt new technologies much sooner than ever before.

Installing Windows 8
Upgrading to Windows 8 via digital distribution is very easy, the installer scans your system for incompatible software and gives the option to burn the ISO to a DVD or to create a bootable USB flash drive. If you run Windows 7 you can do an in-place upgrade that will preserve not only all of your files but also all of your applications and settings, but I recommend a clean install to ensure you don't run into any unexpected compatibility issues and to enjoy the best possible performance.

You also have the option to do a migration to Windows 8, this means the installer will not wipe the partition you're installing Windows 8 to, instead it will move all files currently present on the volume to a folder named "Windows.old". After installing Windows 8, you can then move all documents and files you still need and delete all the rest.

I didn't time it but I estimate the installation of Windows 8 took about half an hour on a HDD. After everything is finished installing, you'll be greeted by the operating system's new user interface.

Faster bootups
One of the big improvements in Windows 8 is the faster bootup time, by default the Windows kernel enters a hibernation mode on shutdown to enable a much faster bootup time. Especially if you have Windows 8 installed on a solid state disk you can expect bootup times of well under ten seconds! It's still not instant-on, but it's getting very close. Additionally, Windows 8 also shuts down faster than previous versions of Windows.

Added:
Product reviewed: Two months with Windows 8
Reviewer:
Score: 8.75/10

[ Back to Reviews Index ]

Thomas De Maesschalck

About the Author

Thomas De Maesschalck

Thomas has been messing with computer since early childhood and firmly believes the Internet is the best thing since sliced bread. Enjoys playing with new tech, is fascinated by science, and passionate about financial markets. When not behind a computer, he can be found with running shoes on or lifting heavy weights in the weight room.
Thanks. Your comment is waiting for moderation.
Your comment was published.

Comments (15)

  1. darks

    They already lost and alienated pc users with this abomination of an OS. Not touching this OS with a 10 foot pole. I’m a Network Admin at an insurance Company, and we already determined that this OS will not ever see the light of day on our PCs. Microsoft has already lost this battle. Everyone is now waiting on Windows 9. Microsoft had better get their heads out from between their asses or they will continue to piss everyone off and windows 7 will be the primary OS for many years to come.

    Reply
  2. BrianAAA

    You got to hand it to microsoft. In addition to sticking to their guns to this metro on PC crap they are also continuing their policy of holding Direct X updates hostage. I don't see why DX 11 can't be made to work in some form on XP, other than getting my money for an OS upgrade. Devlopers are also faced with the decision of using an outdated API (DX9) or lose %40 of the market (XP users). Way to go MS. Maybe 8(metro) will go the way of Bob and ME. Remember those glorious IU innovations? One can only hope.

    Reply
  3. MisterBenn

    How does "risks alienating all existing Windows users" and "poor multitasking" lead to 8.75 out of 10?!?!

    Reply
  4. ThomasDM

    1) I work behind a computer all day and my experience with Windows 8 is that it's 95% (or even more) the same as Windows 7. The risk is mostly in the perception people have about Windows 8, not the actual OS itself. 2) Poor multitasking only applies to multitasking between the desktop environment and the Modern UI. Plain old desktop multitasking obviously hasn't changed. The desktop is still the desktop, it's not like they've turned this into some app that runs into the Modern UI. The good far outweights the bad, that's why I rated this 8.75/10.

    Reply
  5. disqus_RRdqi9oq32

    I wouldn't upgrade to Win8 even if it was for free. As a pc technician I recommend my customers WinXP/Win7 depending on their hardware specs. It surely has a few improvements here and there but in no way is going to make me switch. As a gamer I still find Win7 the best, with most games still running DX9 and supporting WinXP I can rest easy that I can stick to Win7 and hopefully jump to Win9 (provided it's an improvement over Win8), also my current Win7 installation is almost 2 years old and still boots up in around 20 seconds on my normal SATA2 HDD. IMO Win8 is like Vista 2 to me, not worth upgrading.

    Reply
  6. rudybob

    That's it? What a crum article.

    Reply
  7. rudybob

    There is nothing wrong with 8 as long as I have a start button which I do. Classic Shell.

    Reply
  8. RichardB

    Recommending people to install Windows XP in 2013 is a big NO-NO.

    Reply
  9. danehbear

    Thanks for the article. It helped me appreciate Windows 8 more under the hood. Unfortunately end-users I've spoken to really dislike the Metro interface and find it difficult to use; they ask me if there's a way to make it the way it was and I give them the bad news. In my humble opinion, a well designed UI should be intuitive to a basic user, not frustrating even to expert users. I understand the reasons for using the same core for both platforms but because of the clear differences between desktops and tablets, there should be clear differences in the UI to make them intuitive for both; and you'll have a hard time convincing me that this was not possible.

    Reply
  10. danehbear

    Windows 7 vs Windows 8 (first time experience) Printers - Win 7: Start > Devices and printers Printers - Win 8: Start > ? > charms bar > ? > devices > ? > start > charms bar > ? > settings > ? > change pc settings > ? > devices > ? can only delete printers ? > start > type "print" > click settings under search > click devices and printers > whew! Note: you can't pin any control panel/settings items to start Documents - Win 7: Start > Documents Documents - Win 8: Start > ? > charms bar > ? > search > ? > type "documents" > click documents > whew! Shutdown - Win 7: Start > Shut down Shutdown - Win 8: Start > ? > charms bar > ? > settings > ? > power > shut down ? whew!

    Reply
  11. anthony

    My work PC is not fast enough to run 7 properly. Thank god it runs XP and not Vista. It is fast enough for what I do at work (about 1/15 the speed of my gaming computer). Regarding Windows 8. Why is it good that something which is maybe-not-worse-than-7 costs not-much-money. I wouldn't use it for free. Bring on windows 9. Or more likely, Windows 9 Desktop Edition.

    Reply
  12. disqus_p7wb8kcvU7

    Why do you have people who cannot use a computer in charge of what your company uses for computers. Press the windows logo to switch between desktop and windows 8, or click bottom left of the screen. You want to launch a program? Press the start button and type just like you did in Vista and Windows 7. You could locate the programme through Windows explorer but people used the start menu because it was quick and simple in comparison. That's why people type instead of clicking through menus in the start menu. That's why the start menu was removed. It is obsolete and unnecessary.

    Reply
  13. disqus_p7wb8kcvU7

    Only games I have seen that don't support DX9, but higher, are ones that require DX10 minimum. Microsoft does not support DX10 for XP the last time I checked so I don't really see any expectation of DX11 support, not to mention the support dropping from XP -period. I am not sure but I think they have already dropped support for XP and are only providing security updates for a year or so. Whether you can use windows update I am not sure but I think you probably will, just that there won't be new updates. This may be strategy to make money from people buying their new OS, but also they don't have to spend time and money supporting it. You can use windows 8 and not use windows 8 apps. I bought my download 64-bit pro update for £24.99. The only problems I have are; I want to try out using my ram as a cache but the software only supports up to windows 7 currently, and network issues for homegroup. My family have windows 7 but I think there were the same issues when I used windows 7 too.

    Reply
  14. budozero

    Windows 8, they can do what they want. But if you are an IT professional, and have tried working with Server 2012, its a nightmare. Particularly once virtualized, the menus are so rinky dink, spent many headache inducing hours doing remote sessions with customers, trying in vain to do the most simple task due to the at best totally random interface. What GOOD does it bring the user? Besides having an 'app store' built into the OS? Windows 7 seemed a naturally UI progression from XP, you could use the features you wanted and leave those you want. This metro stuff is shoved in your face want it or not and I DONT want it, perticularly in a server os.

    Reply
  15. Chris

    Windows 8 is Windows 7. the only difference is they knocked out the start menu and introduced Metro an application that only makes sense if your screen is a touchscreen. Windows 8 is for tablets and touch screen interfaces. Microsoft's way of putting their foot in the door of today's market like apple's ipad and android devices. However, as much as I disliked it. Company Stardock came out with a solution knowing full well the average user would hate this version of windows. I present to you Start8. You can find it at their website which I won't post out of consideration. Just look up Stardock in Google or Start8. Goes for $4.99. Best money I ever spent. Brings back the start menu. Makes Metro an option not forced. Windows opens to your desktop not metro. Drop and drag features are enabled allowing you to create quick and easy shortcuts to your desktop. If you don't want to spend any money you can try Classic Shell but it completely shuts down metro. Not even an option to launch it. Regards, Chris

    Reply

Reply to budozero

Replying to budozero